Product Quantum (Rs. Cr) Long Term Rating Short Term Rating
Non Convertible Debentures (NCD) 260.00 PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Assigned | Provisional To Final -
Non Convertible Debentures (NCD) 2905.00 PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed -
Non Convertible Debentures (NCD) 340.00 Provisional PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed -
Total Outstanding Quantum (Rs. Cr) 3505.00 - -
Total Withdrawn Quantum (Rs. Cr) 0.00 - -
 
Rating Rationale

­Acuité has reaffirmed its long term rating of ‘PP-MLD ACUITE C’ (read as Principal Protected Market Linked Debenture ACUITE C) on the Rs.2,905.00 Cr Principal Protected Market Linked Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) of Embassy Property Developments Pvt Ltd (EPDPL). ­Acuité has reaffirmed its long term rating of ‘PROVISIONAL PP-MLD ACUITE C’ (read as  PROVISIONAL Principal Protected Market Linked Debenture ACUITE C) on the Rs.340.00 Cr Proposed Principal Protected Market Linked Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) of Embassy Property Developments Pvt Ltd (EPDPL). Acuité has assigned and converted its long term provisional rating to ‘PP-MLD ACUITE C’ (read as Principal Protected Market Linked Debenture ACUITE C) on the Rs.260.00 Cr Principal Protected Market Linked Non-Convertible Debentures (NCDs) of Embassy Property Developments Pvt Ltd (EPDPL).

The rating on the Rs.340.00 Cr NCD remains provisional and the final rating is subject to:
· Appointment of a SEBI registered debenture Trustee
· Receipt of the executed trust deed
· Receipt of the final term sheet and confirmation from trustee regarding the compliance with all the terms and conditions

The rating is an outcome of delays in the Non-NCD debt - construction finance (CF)/lease rental discounting (LRD) loans, established through the CRIF High mark report and on the basis of verbal feedback from one of the lending institutions. To substantiate the default, Acuité had sought the bank statements and sanction letters from EPDPL, which have not been made available to it as on the date of this report. The delay has been reported in servicing a construction finance loan amounting to Rs.82 Cr (outstanding as on October 31, 2022) on account of procedural aspects as well as delays in regulatory approvals for transfer of CF loans to Embassy REIT. Acuité, also understands there are delays in servicing of interest obligations in other CF/LRD loans. The delays reflect the on-going liquidity issues.

The rating takes cognizance of the dilution of REIT units secured against the existing NCDs and usage of the same as security against the proposed NCDs (Rs.340 Cr), high debt levels in the entity as well as at the group level and the uncertainty on the cash flow timelines from monetization/sale of assets to Embassy REIT. The rating also factors in the lowerthanestimated distributions from REIT units secured against the rated NCDs which shall lead to lower principal repayments than previously envisaged. The rating remains constrained by high refinancing risks given the mix of large amount of NCDs and construction finance outstanding as on June 30, 2022. The total debt outstanding for EPDPL as on June 30, 2022 was approximately Rs.4,137.25 Cr (includes the accumulated interest on NCDs) against the sanctioned debt of Rs.4,418.10 Cr.


About the Company

­Embassy Property Developments Private Limited (EPDPL) was incorporated in 1996 and flagship company of leading real estate Embassy Group, based out of Bangalore. EPDPL is engaged in development of commercial, residential and retail projects. Embassy Group was  incorporated in 1993 by Mr. Jitendra Virwani. The group is one of the leading real estate developer. The group has developed 55+ Million Sq. Ft. In its legacy of expertise spanning 25 years, Embassy Group has covered the entire value chain of real estate from land acquisition to the development, marketing and operation of assets. In addition, the Embassy group owns properties in the hospitality segment and is dev eloping industrial parks and warehouses across India. It also has an extensive land bank of 1000+ acres across India. The operation spread across Indian and international markets that include Bangalore, Chennai, Pune, Coimbatore, Trivandrum, Serbia and Malaysia. The group from time to time partners with several established market players Like, Blackstone, Warburg Pincus, Taurus Investments as well as different financial institutions to execute projects.

 
Analytical Approach
­Acuité has considered the standalone business and financial risk profiles of EPDPL to arrive at the rating.
 

Key Rating Drivers

Strengths

­Established presence of Embassy group in the commercial real estate segment
The Embassy group is among the largest commercial real estate developers in the country. EPDPL is engaged in development of commercial, residential and retail projects. The group has business parks in locations such as Bangalore and Pune, with upcoming projects in Chennai, and Trivandrum. The group has developed 55+ Million Sq. Ft. In its legacy of expertise spanning 25 years, Embassy Group has covered the entire value chain of real estate from land acquisition to the development, marketing and operation of assets. In addition, the Embassy Sponsor owns properties in the hospitality segment.

Demonstrated financial flexibility arising from EPDPL’s investments, including Embassy REIT
EPDPL, being the flagship company of the group, has moderate financial flexibility resulting from its investments in the completed commercial real estate portfolio, including its stake in Embassy REIT providing recurring dividend income to EPDPL. In addition, the group sold some of the assets to pare its debt.

Support from group entities and adequate asset coverage
The rating also draws strength from the free cash flow generation from group entities, including the facility management services and common area management companies of the group, which are also the co-borrowers to some of the loans of the company. The asset coverage available against the entire Principal Protected Non - convertible debentures is more than 1.5 times.

Weaknesses

­High Refinancing Risk
EPDPL’s total debt consisted of construction finance, NCDs, term loans and inter corporate deposit from banks, NBFCs, and group companies. The subdued market scenario in the real estate sector in Bangalore from past two years ending FY21 had affected the cash flows from the existing projects leading to higher dependence on the refinancing of the external bank debt. However, the company has successfully refinanced its existing debt obligations in past. Acuité believes that timeliness and adequacy of such refinancing measures resulting into easing of its liquidity position remains a key rating sensitivity factor along with high refinancing risk associated with existing NCDs post the change in security structure for the proposed NCDs.

Susceptibility to cyclicality and regulatory risks impacting real estate industry
EPDPL is exposed to the risk of volatile prices on account of frequent demand supply mismatches in the industry. The Real Estate sector is currently witnessing moderation in demand on account of large amounts of unsold inventory and high borrowing costs, this along with the pandemic has mounted pressure on the industry resulting in lower sales. This is primarily attributable to the high residential property prices due to persistent rollover of bank debt which has had a cascading effect on the overall financing costs. Given the high degree of financial leverage the high cost of borrowing inhibits the real estate developers' ability to reduce prices. Further, the industry is exposed to regulatory risk which is likely to impact players such as EPDPL, thereby impacting its operating capabilities.

ESG Factors Relevant for Rating

­EPDPL undertakes multiple CSR activities and has an existing CSR policy. In FY22, the company has supported for implementing holistic health and hygiene program with focus on preventive healthcare, nutrition and sanitation at government schools in Bangalore. Further, Embassy Group is engaged in multiple ESG initiatives including supporting government schools in Bangalore, public spaces clean up in Bangalore, installation of segregated garbage bins in Bangalore CBD, transformation of 101 under fly-over pillars, among others. Additionally, all the projects undertaken by Embassy Group have IGBC Green Gold Certification or higher. Embassy group has an active engagement towards improvising education, sustainable infrastructure, community engagement and corporate connect. The group aims to facilitate students of Government Schools with a safe learning environment for skill development through holistic interventions in Education, Health and Infrastructure. It has supported more than 85 government schools through educational and infrastructure interventions, build around 10 new government schools amongst others. Embassy group drives positive change by providing infrastructure-based solutions with new frontline services for environmental sustainability and community healthcare, it promotes grassroot results to global problems in the communities it is a part of. Embassy group is a proud partner of TAICT’s (The Anonymous Indian Charitable Trust) Ecogram Waste Management Project, which aims to catalyse communities to develop and implement strategic infrastructure for sustainable environmental management. It has completed several initiatives of public spaces clean-up, installation of segregated garbage, mobile cancer detection unit amongst others.

 
Rating Sensitivities
­Not Applicable
 
Material covenants
None
 
Liquidity: Stretched

­The group operates in real estate business, which to a large extent is illiquid and highly cyclical and it usually takes time monetize these assets. Existing debt of the group includes loans obtained for general corporate purpose and acquisition and are susceptible to refinancing risk. The group in the past has been able to demonstrate moderate financial flexibility and ability to borrow against the value of its investments in various commercial real estate assets and investments. Nevertheless, the company was unable to refinance some of its debt in March 2020 due to the ongoing pandemic.

 
Outlook
­Not Applicable
 
Other Factors affecting Rating
­None
 

Particulars Unit FY 22 (Provisional) FY 21 (Actual)
Operating Income Rs. Cr. 310.42 207.59
PAT Rs. Cr. (89.11) 3597.42
PAT Margin (%) (28.71) 1732.98
Total Debt/Tangible Net Worth Times 1.70 1.83
PBDIT/Interest Times 0.93 4.85
Status of non-cooperation with previous CRA (if applicable)
None­
 
Any other information

­Supplementary disclosures for Provisional Ratings
A. Risks associated with the provisional nature of the credit rating

1. Absence of any entity to take appropriate measures to protect the interest of the debenture holders in case of any breach of the trust deed or law.
2. In case there are material changes in the terms of the transaction after the initial assignment of the provisional rating and post the completion of the issuance (corresponding to the part that has been issued) Acuite will withdraw the existing provisional rating and concurrently, assign a fresh final rating in the same press release, basis the revised terms of the transaction.

B. Rating that would have been assigned in absence of the pending steps/ documentation, the rating would be equated to the standalone rating of the entity: PROVISIONAL PP-MLD ACUITE C.

C. Timeline for conversion to Final Rating for a debt instrument proposed to be issued: The provisional rating shall be converted into a final rating within 90 days from the date of issuance of the proposed debt instrument. Under no circumstance shall the provisional rating continue upon the expiry of 180 days from the date of issuance of the proposed debt instrument.

 
Applicable Criteria
• Default Recognition :- https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-52.htm
• Rating Process and Timeline: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-67.htm
• Application Of Financial Ratios And Adjustments: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-53.htm
• Real Estate Entities: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-63.htm
• Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT): https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-81.htm

Note on complexity levels of the rated instrument

­In order to inform the investors about complexity of instruments, Acuité has categorized such instruments in three levels: Simple, Complex and Highly Complex. Acuite’ s categorisation of the instruments across the three categories is based on factors like variability of the returns to the investors, uncertainty in cash flow patterns, number of counterparties and general understanding of the instrument by the market. It has to be understood that complexity is different from credit risk and even an instrument categorized as 'Simple' can carry high levels of risk. For more details, please refer Rating Criteria “Complexity Level Of Financial Instruments” on www.acuite.in.

 

Date Name of Instruments/Facilities Term Amount (Rs. Cr) Rating/Outlook
30 Nov 2022 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 420.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD C (Assigned)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 180.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD C (Assigned)
11 Nov 2022 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD C (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD C (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD C (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD C (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 750.00 ACUITE PP-MLD C (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable)
06 Sep 2022 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2.84 ACUITE BBB- (Withdrawn)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 750.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative)
02 Aug 2022 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 750.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB- | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2.84 ACUITE BBB- | Negative (Reaffirmed)
02 Aug 2021 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2.84 ACUITE BBB- | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 750.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB- | Stable (Assigned)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
28 Jul 2021 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2.84 ACUITE BBB- | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Proposed Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 750.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD BBB- | Stable (Assigned)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
30 Jun 2021 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2.84 ACUITE BBB- | Stable (Assigned)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
27 Mar 2021 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Assigned)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Assigned)
24 Mar 2021 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 200.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Assigned)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1080.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 275.00 ACUITE PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 600.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Assigned)
12 Jun 2020 Proposed Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2100.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Assigned)
14 Apr 2020 Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 1355.00 ACUITE BBB | Stable (Assigned)
Proposed Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 745.00 ACUITE BBB (Withdrawn)
24 Mar 2020 Proposed Non Convertible Debentures Long Term 2100.00 ACUITE Provisional PP-MLD BBB | Stable (Assigned)
­

Lender’s Name ISIN Facilities Date Of Issuance Coupon Rate Maturity Date Quantum (Rs. Cr.) Complexity Level Rating
Not Applicable INE003L07069 Non-Convertible Debentures (NCD) Apr 3 2020 15 Mar 2 2030 275.00 Simple / Complex PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
Not Applicable INE003L07077 Non-Convertible Debentures (NCD) Apr 3 2020 14.25 Mar 2 2030 1080.00 Simple / Complex PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
Not Applicable INE003L07150 Non-Convertible Debentures (NCD) Mar 26 2021 13.75 Apr 28 2023 600.00 Simple / Complex PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
Not Applicable INE003L07168 Non-Convertible Debentures (NCD) Mar 26 2021 13.75 Apr 28 2023 200.00 Simple / Complex PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
Not Applicable INE003L07184 Non-Convertible Debentures (NCD) Jul 30 2021 12.00 Jul 30 2026 750.00 Simple / Complex PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
Not Applicable INE003L07200 Non-Convertible Debentures (NCD) Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 260.00 Simple / Complex PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Assigned | Provisional To Final
Not Applicable Not Applicable Proposed Non Convertible Debentures Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 180.00 Simple / Complex Provisional PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
Not Applicable Not Applicable Proposed Non Convertible Debentures Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 160.00 Simple / Complex Provisional PP-MLD | ACUITE C | Reaffirmed
­

Contacts
Analytical Rating Desk
About Acuité Ratings & Research

Acuité Ratings & Research Limitedwww.acuite.in