Product Quantum (Rs. Cr) Long Term Rating Short Term Rating
Bank Loan Ratings 21.60 - ACUITE A4+ | Downgraded
Total Outstanding 21.60 - -
Total Withdrawn 0.00 - -
 
Rating Rationale

Acuité has downgraded the short-term rating of ‘ACUITÉ A3’ (read as ACUITÉ A three) to ‘ACUITÉ A4+’ (read as ACUITÉ A four plus) on the Rs. 21.60 Cr. bank facilities of Calcutta Export Company (CEC).

 Rationale for Rating
The rating reflects the significant decline in the firm’s revenue due to the geopolitical issues leading to reduced orders and also due to labour unrest in one of the production plant leading to suspension of production in the same, resulting in a 45.24% decrease in topline. Reduced production capacity and reliance on job work have pressured profitability, as seen in the drop in EBITDA and PAT margins from 10.31% and 6.25% in FY24 against 15.14% and 9.36% in FY23, respectively. The firm’s high customer concentration, with 80- 90% of sales dependent on a single US customer, further increases risk. Additionally, the financial risk profile has weakened with a decrease in net worth, reduced cash accruals, and a longer working capital cycle albeit low gearing and absence of any long-term debt.


About the Company

CEC a Kolkata based firm was formed in 2000 by Mr. Bhagwan Das Agarwal. Currently the firm is promoted by Mr. Bhagwan Das Agarwal, Mrs. Priti Jhunjhunwala and Mrs. Jyoti Gupta. The firm is engaged in manufacturing of iron casting for manhole, pipe fittings, and valve box among others with an installed capacity of 36000 MTPA in 2 plants. Since August 2023, operations in one of the plant have been suspended. The firm has its manufacturing facility located in Rabindra Sarani and Howrah, West Bengal.

 
Unsupported Rating

­Not Applicable

 
Analytical Approach

­Acuité has considered the standalone business and financial risk profile of CEC while arriving at the rating.

 
Key Rating Drivers

Strengths

Long track record of operation and experienced management
CEC, a Kolkata based firm, was incorporated in 2000 by Mr. Bhagwan Das Agarwal. Currently the firm is managed by Mr. Bhagwan Das Agarwal, who possesses more than two decades of experience in iron casting business especially in manufacturing of manhole, pipe fittings, valve box among others. The other partners, Mrs. Priti Jhunjhunwala and Mrs. Jyoti Gupta also have more than a decade experience in aforementioned industry. The firm has a long presence in this sector and has established a healthy relationship with customers over the years.
Moderate financial risk profile
The firm’s financial risk profile is currently moderate, with a decline in net worth albeit low gearing, and no long-term debt. Net worth decreased to Rs. 28.65 Cr. in FY24 from Rs. 37.23 Cr. in FY23, mainly due to a Rs. 16.12 Cr. capital withdrawal by the partners. Gearing remained healthy at 0.61 times as of March 31, 2024, due to a debt-free structure. Interest coverage ratio (ICR) and debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) moderated to 13.06 times and 8.80 times in FY24, from 23.03 times and 15.12 times in FY23, while the net cash accruals to total debt (NCA/TD) ratio decreased to 0.41 times in FY24 from 0.92 times in FY23. Acuité expects the financial risk profile to improve in the absence of any major debt-funded capital expenditure over the medium term albeit risk of capital withdrawal.


Weaknesses

Intensive working capital operations
The firm’s working capital management is intensive. GCA days increased to 196 days in FY24 from 125 days in FY23, with debtor days rising to 95 days in FY24 from 63 days in FY23 due to a longer payment cycle amid the US economic slowdown. Inventory days also rose sharply to 79 days in FY24 from 39 days in FY23 as the firm had to hold on to finished goods due to geopolitical reasons. The creditor cycle extended to 41 days in FY24 from 18 days in FY23. Acuité expects working capital cycles to remain in a similar range as the firm shifts focus from manufacturing to job work, leading to longer cycles.
Partnership nature of business
The firm is exposed to risk of capital withdrawal considering its partnership nature of constitution of the business. There have been instances in the past for capital withdrawal, but the promoters have maintained the funds required for operations of the business. There was a net withdrawal of capital from business amounting to Rs.16.12 Cr. in FY24 resulting its working capital cycle to elongate. The GCA increased to196 days in FY24 from 125 days in FY23. Acuite believes, the management will maintain the capital required for proper functioning of the business.
Customer concentration risk
The firm is also susceptible to customer concentration risk as on average~80-90% percent of the firm’s revenue is generated through sales to one US based customer. However, the firm is taking the initiative to diversify its customer base. Acuité believes that the ability of CEC to expand its customer base to mitigate the revenue concentration risk will remain a key rating sensitivity factor.

 

Rating Sensitivities

Movement in revenue growth and profitability margin
Movement in capital structure
Working capital cycle
Movement of order book

 
Liquidity Position
Adequate

The firm has adequate liquidity position marked by comfortable albeit decreased net cash accruals of Rs. 7.17 Cr. as against nil maturing debt repayment obligations. The current ratio of the firm stood comfortable at 1.59 times in FY24. The Gross Current Asset (GCA) days of the firm stood high at 196 days in FY24. Bank limits utilization is moderate at ~65% during the last 6 months ending November 2024. The firm avails PCFC facility on bill-to-bill basis on export orders typically of a tenure of 6 months. The same can also be evidenced from the debtor days as of Dec 2024 which is 118 days. The liquidity of the firm is likely to remain adequate over the medium term on account of average albeit decreased cash accruals against nil debt repayments obligations albeit increase in working capital cycle and withdrawal oi capital from business over the medium term.

 
Outlook: Not Applicable
­
 
Other Factors affecting Rating

None

 

Particulars Unit FY 24 (Actual) FY 23 (Actual)
Operating Income Rs. Cr. 106.74 194.93
PAT Rs. Cr. 6.67 18.25
PAT Margin (%) 6.25 9.36
Total Debt/Tangible Net Worth Times 0.61 0.55
PBDIT/Interest Times 13.06 23.03
Status of non-cooperation with previous CRA (if applicable)

­Not Applicable

 
Any other information

­None

 
Applicable Criteria
• Default Recognition :- https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-52.htm
• Manufacturing Entities: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-59.htm
• Application Of Financial Ratios And Adjustments: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-53.htm

Note on complexity levels of the rated instrument

Date Name of Instruments/Facilities Term Amount (Rs. Cr) Rating/Outlook
30 Oct 2023 Letter of Credit Short Term 2.00 ACUITE A3 (Reaffirmed)
PC/PCFC Short Term 19.60 ACUITE A3 (Reaffirmed)
01 Aug 2022 Letter of Credit Short Term 2.00 ACUITE A3 (Reaffirmed)
PC/PCFC Short Term 19.60 ACUITE A3 (Reaffirmed)
­

Lender’s Name ISIN Facilities Date Of Issuance Coupon Rate Maturity Date Quantum
(Rs. Cr.)
Complexity Level Rating
Punjab National Bank Not avl. / Not appl. Letter of Credit Not avl. / Not appl. Not avl. / Not appl. Not avl. / Not appl. 2.00 Simple ACUITE A4+ | Downgraded ( from ACUITE A3 )
Punjab National Bank Not avl. / Not appl. PC/PCFC Not avl. / Not appl. Not avl. / Not appl. Not avl. / Not appl. 19.60 Simple ACUITE A4+ | Downgraded ( from ACUITE A3 )

Contacts

About Acuité Ratings & Research

© Acuité Ratings & Research Limited. All Rights Reserved.www.acuite.in