Product Quantum (Rs. Cr) Long Term Rating Short Term Rating
Bank Loan Ratings 106.00 - ACUITE D | Downgraded
Bank Loan Ratings 110.09 ACUITE C | Downgraded -
Bank Loan Ratings 110.94 ACUITE D | Downgraded -
Total Outstanding Quantum (Rs. Cr) 327.03 - -
Total Withdrawn Quantum (Rs. Cr) 0.00 - -
 
Rating Rationale

Acuité has downgraded the long-term rating to ‘ACUITE D’ (read as ACUITE D) from ‘ACUITE BB+’ (read as ACUITE double B plus) and short-term rating to 'ACUITE D' (read as ACUITE D) from 'ACUITE A4+' (read as ACUITE A four plus) on Rs.216.94 Cr. bank facilities of ARS Energy Pvt Ltd (AEPL).
Further, Acuité has also downgraded the long-term rating to ‘ACUITE C’ (read as ACUITE C) from ‘ACUITE BB+’ (read as ACUITE double B plus) on the Rs.110.09 Cr. bank facilities of ARS Energy Pvt Ltd (AEPL).

Rationale for rating downgrade
The rating downgrade in AEPL reflects the overdrawings in its cash credit account and devolvement of its letter of credit (LC), leading to the classification of the account as Non-Performing Asset (NPA) in September 2022 as per banking sources. The rating also factors in the intensive working capital operations and poor liquidity position of the company.


About the Company

ARS Energy Private Limited (Previously known as ARS Metals Private Limited) is a Tamil Nadu based company incorporated in the year 1990, promoted by Mr. Ashwani Kumar Bhatia. It operates 60 megawatt (MW) thermal power plant in Gummidipoondi (Chennai), Tamil Nadu in 2013. The power generated is sold to private parties under group captive system. Further, the company is also engaged in trading of coal.

 
Analytical Approach
­Acuité has considered the standalone business and financial risk profiles of AEPL to arrive at this rating
 

Key Rating Drivers

Strengths

­Established track record of operations with experienced management
ARS Energy Private Limited (formerly known as ARS Metals Private Ltd) is the power division of the ARS Group which was promoted by Mr. Ashwani Kumar Bhatia in the year 1990. Mr. Bhatia has more than three decades of experience in steel industry. Later, in October 2013, the promoter decided to use his experience to diversify the business into two divisions i.e. Steel & Power and set up a 60-MW thermal power plant in the same year. This led to demerger of its steel division and name of the company ARS Metals Private Ltd was changed to ARS Energy Private Limited (AEPL). 
Acuite believes that the company will benefit from the experience of the management along the company's established track record of operations

Weaknesses

Overdrawing and devolvement of working capital limits
The liquidity profile of the company is stretched marked by the overdrawings in the cash credit facilities along with the devolvement in the letter of credit in September 2022.

Declining sales and profitability
ARS Energy Private Ltd (AEPL) has registered a degrowth of 40.74% in its topline. The revenue stood at Rs.140.34 Cr in FY2021 as against Rs.236.83 Cr in FY2020. Such decline in revenue comes at the back of low manufacturing activities of its clients on account of Covid-19 leading to a decline in Plant Load factor (PLF) in FY2021. The average PLF in FY2021 was 52.66% as against 76.04% in FY2020. The overall tied capacity of the plant however improved from 41.28 MW in FY2020 to 46.84 MW in FY2022 on account of renewal of certain PPA’s. AEPL’s plant was shut between October 2021 to December 2021 on account of leakage in tube in furnace and radiography test carried out in the power plant. Hence, the average PLF for FY2022 stood at ~35.56%. As of March 2022, AEPL has registered Rs.109.49Cr (Prov) of revenue with a Y-o-Y decline of 23.34% in FY2022. EBITDA margins of the company declined by 967 bps form 20.50% in FY2020 to 10.83 % in FY2021. Such decline is majorly on account of increase in raw material prices. Tariff charged to the customers is fixed at the time of entering the PPA agreement. AEPL can revise the tariff charged only in the event of revision in prices by TNEB (Tamil Nadu Electricity Board).Hence, the company cannot pass the fluctuations in coal prices to the customers. PAT margins have also declined from 0.92% in FY2020 to -20.36% in FY2021. The EBITDA margin and PAT margins for FY2022 (Prov) remained negative at 7.36% and 49.77%.
Acuite believes that the improvement in Plant load factor and profitability levels will remain key sensitivities factors in the medium term.

Intensive working capital operations
The working capital operations of the company remain intensive marked by Gross Current Asset (GCA) days of 275 days in FY2021 as against 196 days in FY2020 driven by elongated debtor and inventory days. AEPL raises bills to the customers on a monthly basis and extends a period of 7 days for payment. Debtor days stood at 41 days in FY2021 as against 21 days in FY2020. As a policy, AEPL maintains inventory sufficient for 60-90 days of operations and trades the coal over and above its requirement. The company in the current year has stopped trading of coal on account of the fluctuations in prices. Inventory days stood at 176 days in FY2021 as against 163 days in FY2020. AEPL opens LC of 180 days for purchase of coal. The creditor days stood at 127 days in FY2021 as against 175 days in FY2020.
Acuité believes that the operations of the company to remain working capital intensive on account of high inventory levels maintained by the company for regular supply of power.

Rating Sensitivities

No overdrawings and devolvement in the working capital limits

 
Material covenants

­Current ratio to be maintained above 1.33 times.
TOL/TNW to be maintained less than 4.00 times

 
Liquidity: Poor

The company has a poor liquidity position marked by the overdrawings and devolvement in the working capital limits and classification of account as Non-performing asset as per banking sources. The company generated negative cash accruals of Rs.7.89 crore in FY21. The company maintains unencumbered cash and bank balances of Rs.1.10 crore as on March 31, 2021 and the current ratio also stood moderate at 1.81 times as on March 31, 2021.

 
Outlook:
­Not applicable
 

Particulars Unit FY 21 (Actual) FY 20 (Actual)
Operating Income Rs. Cr. 140.34 236.83
PAT Rs. Cr. (28.57) 2.18
PAT Margin (%) (20.36) 0.92
Total Debt/Tangible Net Worth Times 1.79 1.31
PBDIT/Interest Times 0.67 1.91
Status of non-cooperation with previous CRA (if applicable)
­None
 
Any other information
­The company has been classified as Non-performing asset as on September 2022 as per the written feedback from received from lenders. However, the company has continued to submit No Default Statement for the month of October and November stating no defaults leading to misrepresentation of details to Acuite.
 
Applicable Criteria
• Default Recognition :- https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-52.htm
• Manufacturing Entities: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-59.htm
• Application Of Financial Ratios And Adjustments: https://www.acuite.in/view-rating-criteria-53.htm

Note on complexity levels of the rated instrument

­In order to inform the investors about complexity of instruments, Acuité has categorized such instruments in three levels: Simple, Complex and Highly Complex. Acuite’ s categorisation of the instruments across the three categories is based on factors like variability of the returns to the investors, uncertainty in cash flow patterns, number of counterparties and general understanding of the instrument by the market. It has to be understood that complexity is different from credit risk and even an instrument categorized as 'Simple' can carry high levels of risk. For more details, please refer Rating Criteria “Complexity Level Of Financial Instruments” on www.acuite.in.

 

Date Name of Instruments/Facilities Term Amount (Rs. Cr) Rating/Outlook
06 Jun 2022 Term Loan Long Term 35.90 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Letter of Credit Short Term 56.25 ACUITE A4+ (Downgraded from ACUITE A2+)
Term Loan Long Term 1.18 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Cash Credit Long Term 9.38 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Cash Credit Long Term 15.63 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 8.07 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Bank Guarantee Short Term 2.25 ACUITE A4+ (Downgraded from ACUITE A2+)
Proposed Bank Facility Long Term 2.36 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 28.71 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 9.78 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Letter of Credit Short Term 43.75 ACUITE A4+ (Downgraded from ACUITE A2+)
Term Loan Long Term 38.99 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 10.16 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 43.10 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 8.25 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Term Loan Long Term 1.99 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
Bank Guarantee Short Term 3.75 ACUITE A4+ (Downgraded from ACUITE A2+)
Term Loan Long Term 7.53 ACUITE BB+ | Stable (Downgraded from ACUITE BBB+ | Negative)
03 Feb 2021 Letter of Credit Short Term 43.75 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Bank Guarantee Short Term 2.25 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Letter of Credit Short Term 56.25 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 55.09 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 1.42 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Cash Credit Long Term 15.62 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 44.16 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Cash Credit Long Term 9.38 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 35.70 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Bank Guarantee Short Term 3.75 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 9.79 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 49.87 ACUITE BBB+ | Negative (Reaffirmed)
06 Nov 2019 Bank Guarantee Short Term 3.75 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Bank Guarantee Short Term 2.25 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Letter of Credit Short Term 56.25 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 1.42 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 55.09 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Cash Credit Long Term 9.38 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 35.70 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 44.16 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 9.79 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Cash Credit Long Term 15.62 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Term Loan Long Term 49.87 ACUITE BBB+ | Stable (Reaffirmed)
Letter of Credit Short Term 43.75 ACUITE A2+ (Reaffirmed)
­

Lender’s Name ISIN Facilities Date Of Issuance Coupon Rate Maturity Date Quantum (Rs. Cr.) Complexity Level Rating
Canara Bank Not Applicable Bank Guarantee/Letter of Guarantee Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 2.25 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Bank of Baroda Not Applicable Bank Guarantee/Letter of Guarantee Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 3.75 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Canara Bank Not Applicable Cash Credit Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 9.38 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Bank of Baroda Not Applicable Cash Credit Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 15.63 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Canara Bank Not Applicable Letter of Credit Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 56.25 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Bank of Baroda Not Applicable Letter of Credit Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 43.75 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Not Applicable Not Applicable Proposed Long Term Bank Facility Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable 2.36 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
HDFC Bank Ltd Not Applicable Term Loan Not available Not available Not available 1.18 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
Canara Bank Not Applicable Term Loan May 25 2017 9.60 Sep 9 2031 38.99 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Bank of Baroda Not Applicable Term Loan Jun 17 2017 9.85 Sep 9 2031 28.71 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
HDFC Bank Ltd Not Applicable Term Loan Jun 8 2017 8.65 Sep 9 2031 8.25 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
Punjab National Bank Not Applicable Term Loan Mar 21 2017 9.40 Sep 9 2031 35.90 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
State Bank of India Not Applicable Term Loan Jun 16 2017 11.00 Sep 9 2031 43.10 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
Canara Bank Not Applicable Term Loan Not available Not available Not available 10.16 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
Bank of Baroda Not Applicable Term Loan Not available Not available Not available 8.07 Simple ACUITE D | Downgraded
HDFC Bank Ltd Not Applicable Term Loan Not available Not available Not available 1.99 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
Punjab National Bank Not Applicable Term Loan Not available Not available Not available 7.53 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded
State Bank of India Not Applicable Term Loan Not available Not available Not available 9.78 Simple ACUITE C | Downgraded

Contacts
Analytical Rating Desk
About Acuité Ratings & Research

Acuité Ratings & Research Limitedwww.acuite.in